Sporting Kansas City's Best Starting XI: Preseason Edition
Now that the 2012 MLS SuperDraft has concluded, and Sporting Kansas City's training camp is officially underway, I thought ,"Why not take a look at the club's roster, and attempt to come up with a Starting XI, as well as first off the bench for each position?"
A lot of these are complete shoo-ins. Everyone knows the four players that will make up Kansas City's back line at the start of the season, but there are a couple of spots where things are a little more interesting.
Sporting has made a number of off-season moves, including the acquisitions of Bobby Convey, Paulo Nagamura, and Jacob Peterson. Out of the three new players, I would imagine Convey will be the only starter... at least on opening day.
I've written a little bit about Convey in the past. I actually think that Convey replacing Bravo on the left wing will help Kansas City's attack, as Bobby is a natural left winger, and he'll be looking much more to set up our center forwards with crosses into the box. Bravo spent much of his time cutting back into the middle of the pitch. Come to think of it, I really can't remember seeing Bravo cross a ball.
I can also envision Nagamura perhaps working his way into the starting lineup in the midfield alongside Graham Zusi and Julio Cesar somewhere down the line, especially if Roger Espinoza can't learn to control his emotions and exercise better judgement on the field more than what he has in the past.
I still think there is a chance that the club will bring in a designated player to play attacking midfield, but at this point, I'm not so sure that the club would be best served doing so (Robb Heineman tweeted earlier today that a DP signing in this window is unlikely at this point).
So as the roster stands, here's my projected Sporting Kansas City lineup, including a list of the players I think will round out the squad's best 18 at this point.
Bench
Center Forward- CJ Sapong
Wingers- Jacob Peterson
Midfielders- Paulo Nagamura, Michael Thomas
Fullback- Michael Harrington
Center back- Lawrence Olum
Goalkeeper- Eric Kronberg
Notes:
- I've stated my opinion on the Teal/ CJ debate numerous times over the course of last season. CJ's the better overall player, but Teal will continue to start at center forward, allowing CJ to sub in where ever he's needed on a match to match basis.
- I could have easily listed Daneil Cyrus instead of Olum at center back depth, but I'll give Olum the nod because Daneil missed so much time last season, and because there's been talk that his loan deal will end in March. I do think rookie Cyprian Hedrick will factor in at some point in the season, just not in the early going.
- Wasn't too sure on whether I should put Michael Thomas or Peterson Joseph as the second midfielder off of the bench at this point, but I just have a feeling that Thomas, who I see as being the pro typical "Vermes" player, is going to have an impressive preseason. We didn't get to see much of Joseph last season, so we're still waiting to see why he's known as the "Haitian Xavi."
- I see Jacob Peterson as the first winger off the bench (not that there are many options) for Kansas City at the moment, more because of his previous MLS experience than anything related to skills. I think Vermes gives him the nod over a player like Dom Dwyer at the start. Of course, Dwyer could end up setting the world on fire, and he could easily force his way into some decent minutes.
- It will be interesting to see how Soony Saad's 2012 season plays out. The team is absolutely stacked at the striker position, and with the arrival of Dwyer, Saad could be even more hard pressed for playing time. I think Saad would have to be over Dwyer depth wise as of right now, but that could change if Dwyer is as explosive as the reports make him out to be.
- I'm definitely liking what I've heard from Michael Harrington so far. Sounds like he's looking to make the best out of his situation as the back up to both Chance Myers, and Seth Sinovic. I wouldn't be surprised if Harrington has a bounce back year in 2012.
11 comments
|
0 recs |
Do you like this story?
Comments
I think CJ will start over Bunbury.
As for the subs, Saad over Michael Thomas.
Sporting KC will win the 2012 MLS Cup, the Chiefs will win the 2014 Super Bowl, the Royals will win the 2053 World Series.
by Soccer Over Football on Jan 25, 2012 8:46 AM CST reply actions
Say what now?
Bunbury had 9 goals last year and just started for the USMNT. Unless he’s away on Olympics duty or injured, no way he’s not starting.
I think if Vermes simply started the best player, CJ would get the nod.
But the fact that CJ is versatile, and Teal can only play one position, pretty much means Teal should start at CF most matches.
TheDailyWiz.com
SBNationKansasCity.com
twitter.com/TheDailyWizKC
by justinmayhugh on Jan 26, 2012 1:49 AM CST up reply actions
Nagamura
Hope you’re wrong about Nagamura. He would be much better for us than Cesar.
You weren't a fan of Cesar playing holding midfielder last season?
TheDailyWiz.com
SBNationKansasCity.com
twitter.com/TheDailyWizKC
by justinmayhugh on Jan 26, 2012 1:50 AM CST up reply actions
I think that a lot of PV's genius for this year...
Is going to be evident as USMNT call ups happen, and (if as expected) SKC goes on an extended Open Cup run. This team is starting to field some real depth, and if the same trio that’s playing panama tonight gets called up in the middle if the season, the Saad/Dwyer depth “issue” will be a good problem to have.
Bet me!
by TigerBartender on Jan 25, 2012 10:21 AM CST via mobile reply actions
Top 18
I don’t disagree with anything really. Everyone should expect that starting 11 (with CJ as a possible inclusion) 4 bench spots are locked up (Kronberg, Harrington, Nagamura and CJ). That gives you 3 spots that will likely be filled by a CB (Cyrus, Olum or Hedrick), Winger (Dwyer, Saad, Peterson) and another MF (Thomas or Peterson). Those are all good battles and will be so enterchangable from game to game it’s hard to see it being that big of a deal. Form/Injuries will be deciding factors on those last 3 spots. I heard Dwyer is naturally left footed and I believe Soony is right footed. I hope they get a lot of work on crossing as I’d love to see the reserve forward line of Dwyer, CJ, Saad get some PT together to see if they can all mix on the same line. If those two (Dwyer and Saad) can become more versitle and play the wing we’re set up much better for the future!
Blando
Def. agree that a depth chart isn’t a big deal with SKC. I agree that we will have so many players interchanging, it won’t really matter. I still think it’s a little fun to try and guess what the opening day roster will look like.
TheDailyWiz.com
SBNationKansasCity.com
twitter.com/TheDailyWizKC
by justinmayhugh on Jan 26, 2012 1:53 AM CST up reply actions
I agree with Justin's projections on defense and up top
I think the back line and the wingers + striker are set.
But I think the only midfielder right now guaranteed to be in the Starting XI is Graham Zusi. I think that a healthy Paulo Nagamura will get a long look from PV for a starting spot, which means that either Julio Cesar or Roger Espinoza is out of a starting gig, since Nagamura can play well at either position.
As for the bench, I think Justin’s projections are probably correct, though if Luke Sassano is healthy, I think he has to be considered for a spot in the 18 as a backup mid. No way SKC would have brought him back otherwise.
from what I have read on Dwyer
he seems like’d he be a better bench option as he is allegedly an explosive type. Peterson might be better getting starts during times when Kei/Teal/CJ are on international duty.
If Nagamura is healthy, I think he competes for a starting position. He is a natural CM that adds more going forward than Espinoza or Cesar do. Plus, given Cesar’s age and Espinoza’s erracticness, he (if healthy) is a guy that would be reliable for 90 minutes.
by Howard the Drake on Jan 25, 2012 2:06 PM CST reply actions
Can't disagree with this.
Cesar is going to be 33, so Nagamura could be the heir apparent in that holding role.
TheDailyWiz.com
SBNationKansasCity.com
twitter.com/TheDailyWizKC
by justinmayhugh on Jan 26, 2012 1:54 AM CST up reply actions

by 














